Skip Navigation

July Vol 3, Featured Articles, National News

Zimbabwe at risk of becoming a failed state - report

By Staff reporter and agencies   Wed, Jul 22, 2009

There were few surprises at the top of the list – Somalia topped it for the second year running, with Zimbabwe and Sudan nipping at its heels.

Zimbabwe at risk of becoming a failed state - report

There were few surprises at the top of the list – Somalia topped it for the second year running, with Zimbabwe and Sudan nipping at its heels. The complete top 10 (or bottom 10, depending how you see it) were:

1. Somalia
2. Zimbabwe
3. Sudan
4. Chad
5. Democratic Republic of the Congo
6. Iraq
7. Afghanistan
8. Central African Republic
9. Guinea
10. Pakistan

The rankings were accompanied by intriguing analysis about which countries are growing more vulnerable and why, when it comes to threats to global stability, not all troubled states are created equal.

Economic crisis heightens risk

The magazine argues that the global economic crisis could push a number of weak states into outright failure and says that if that happens, world leaders will pick and choose who gets helped, and who gets left behind.

Now more than ever, failed-state triage could become a grim necessity for world leaders…which puts a fine point on an old and uncomfortable dilemma: Whom do you help when so many need it?”

It is also a harsh fact that a greater risk of failure is not always synonymous with greater consequences of failure. For example, Zimbabwe (No. 2 on the index) is technically failing more than Iraq (6), but the geopolitical implications of state failure in Iraq would be far greater than in Zimbabwe. It’s why we worry more about Pakistan (10) than Guinea (9), and North Korea (17) more than the Ivory Coast (11).

Who were the big movers? Yemen – which “many worry … is the next Afghanistan: a global problem wrapped in a failed state” and where a “perfect storm of state failure is now brewing” – jumped four spots to No. 18 on the list.

Iran leapt 11 spots to 38 as the magazine punished it for a macroeconomic mismanagement (inflation was 30 percent there last year) and Georgia rose 23 places to 33 “due to a substantial spike in that elusive indicator, ‘Invaded by Russia.’ ”

Flawed methodology, critics say

Not everyone is buying FP’s methodology, however. The magazine also carries a critical essay by Robert Rotberg, director of the conflict resolution program at the Kennedy School of Government, who says the fact that Zimbabwe is ranked No. 2 on the list, points to flaws. Zimbabwe’s “government does prey harshly on any opposition, but the Zimbabwean state has not lost its monopoly control of violence and should therefore not be considered failed.”

Somalia: Too lawless even for Al Qaeda

Hardly anyone disagrees with Somalia at No. 1, however, a country suffering so badly that it challenges the conventional wisdom that failed states are Al Qaeda’s favorite havens.

A 2007 analysis of captured Al Qaeda documents by West Point’s Combating Terrorism Center, after all, found that Osama bin Laden’s operatives were exasperated by operational conditions while based there in the 1990s.

“The country’s lawlessness and isolation-which many cite as ideal for al-Qa’ida’s efforts-were seen by the group as constraining their ability to create a secure base for operations.”

By Staff reporter and agencies

Please login to post your comments.

More Featured Articles

CAUGHT CHEATING? HOW TO MOVE FORWARD AFTER BEING UNFAITHFUL

We all learn to look out for signs that our man is cheating, or subtle hints that he might be seeing someone else on the side, but what if you are the one that cheated? Assuming that you still want to work on your current relationship, we have 7 ways to move on successfully after you’ve been unfaithful. This is not a “loop-hole” and is not praised, but the reality is 14 percent of married women have had affairs at least once during their married lives and 17 percent of divorces in the United States are caused by infidelity. If you fall into this category, and don’t want to be part of the divorce statistic, take a look at these helpful steps.

Sure signs she's cheating on you

MARRIAGES often break down on account of husbands not being loyal to their wives.

Who wants to be a monkey?

A student has been left feeling a little red-faced after an embarrassing incident with a monkey made her a global star. Charmian Chen, who just happens to be a model, was visiting the Sacred Monkey Forest Ubud in Bali last month when two of the primates decided she was a little overdressed.The 22-year-old student, from Taiwan, was on holiday on the tropical Indonesian island feeding long-tailed macaques when she was singled out.

Zimbabwean farmers evicted without payment

Many of Zimbabwe's farmers are still waiting for compensation following government land seizures, writes Helen for UK's Channel 4.

Out of Zimbabwe, a telecoms boss means serious business in Africa

Strive Masiyiwa has become an expert at walking the fine line between business and politics. He had to. The man once picked by Time magazine as one of its 15 "global influentials" – he regularly rubs shoulders with Nelson Mandela and former UN secretary general Kofi Annan in his charity work, and was picked by the Rockefeller Foundation to join its board of trustees six years ago – started his working life in Zimbabwe after the civil war and still has thousands of employees there, despite not having returned to the troubled country for nine years writes UK's Daily Telegraph.

Zimbabwe dispatches: attacking the helpless

New evictions of farm workers and the vulnerable are forcing an estimated 150,000 out of work and the problem is going unnoticed, writes Helen of UK's Channel 4.

Political violence growing in rural areas

HARARE, - Families are turning on each other in Zimbabwe's rural areas, where a higher premium is being placed on political allegiance to either President Robert Mugabe's ZANU-PF party or Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), than ties of blood.

Zuma needs to take lead on Zimbabwe - Athol Trollip

DA parliamentary leader says SA president must hold line against Mugabe

Global Post: Western envoys tough with Mugabe

HARARE, Zimbabwe — President Robert Mugabe is a bitter man.

SOUTH AFRICA: Violent protests "worrying but not surprising"

JOHANNESBURG, - Protesters have again brought violence to township streets throughout South Africa over state failure to deliver on longstanding promises of housing and social services for all, but the discontent and frustration run much deeper.

ZIMBABWE: When the cops are the robbers

HARARE, - The demise of the all-but-worthless Zimbabwe dollar and its replacement with foreign currency is being mirrored by a rise in violent crime, perpetrated particularly by police officers.

Methodists see dream of health clinic realized in Zimbabwe

Two years ago, Bishop Alfred Norris laid down a challenge for the North Texas United Methodist Conference: Raise enough money to build a health clinic at the Methodist-affiliated Africa University in Zimbabwe.

Zimbabwe business must build its integrity

ZIMBABWE is currently swamped by investor conferences. The perception of rich pickings at rock-bottom prices and the search for new capital by the public and private sectors have raised the business profile of a country no one wanted to visit a year ago. And despite the flaws of the unity government, the economy is starting to turn around. by DIANNA GAMES

Zimbabwe youths speak on constitution-making process

THE ZYM notes that the All Stakeholders Constitutional Conference on the 13-14th of July had come and gone as per the dictates of the Global Political Agreement.

Zimbabwe: A strange place indeed

On the side of the main highway near Harare there's a hand painted sign on a piece of battered tin. 'Bricks 4 Sale,' it says, the message wedged into a forked stick. Standing in a forlorn heap alongside are the very bricks. Its a sad little assortment of rubble: lumps of red, odd sized, second hand bricks with eroded edges, cracks and chips and some even with splotches of white paint on them.

ZIMBABWE: HIV-Aids ignorance among female students

Zimbabwe's female university students are mainly ignorant of HIV-Aids as well as their sexual and reproductive health rights, a new survey has concluded.

To anyone who cares – this is Zimbabwe

(CHEGUTU)I write this in the wake of the recent letter I wrote to the Prime minister regarding “where Truth becomes the casualty.” The letter was about the widespread break down in the rule of law on the farms in Chegutu District.

Obama and Zimbabwe

I WISH to respectfully disagree with President Barack Obama of the United States on the true cause of the Zimbabwean economic and political crisis. During his recent state visit to Ghana, he was of the opinion that the economic crisis in Zimbabwe was not caused by colonialism but by bad leadership.(By Taiwo Akerele)

Mutsa Murenje - Time to Change the Rules

Legislation that allows the Zimbabwean president to pass new laws without parliamentary approval in times of crisis is open to abuse, warns Mutsa Murenje. Highlighting the dangers that the Presidential Powers Act poses to democracy, Murenje calls on all Zimbabweans to increase their awareness of the country's legislation so that they can challenge and 'say no to evil laws'.

By Eddie Cross: Redeeming disaster

There can be little doubt that the "fast track land reform programme" launched by Zanu PF in 2000 has been an unmitigated disaster. Not only has it resulted in agricultural output declining over 70 per cent but all the industries that were built up to supply agriculture with its many needs and those companies that depended on farm output for raw materials, have suffered collapse.

SOUTH AFRICA: Lesbians and HIV - low risk is not no risk

JOHANNESBURG, - Women who sleep with women (WSW) are not at risk of HIV transmission – or are they? AIDS advocates warn that it is time for a wake-up call about who is and is not at risk.

DNA leads to African roots

Atlanta - To get a sense of the pain many black Americans feel about their broken connection to Africa, just listen to the cries of joy when the divide was bridged by blacks who used DNA to trace their roots to a specific country:

Catholics in Zimbabwe work to get citizen input into new constitution

CAPE TOWN, South Africa (CNS) -- Catholic officials in Zimbabwe said they are working to involve ordinary Zimbabweans in a constitutional consultation, although many people fear retribution

Government in Two Minds About the Rule of Law

HARARE - The Zimbabwean government’s international investment conference at the end of last week did little to assuage fears that the country remains far away from re-establishing the rule of law and stopping land invasions.(By Stanley Kwenda )

Obama's speech 'arrogant'

United States President Barack Obama delivered a much-anticipated speech in Ghana this past weekend; and the speech - from where I am sitting - did not live up to expectations. Without its trademark Obama rhetoric, the speech was an arrogant denial of the destructive role that successive Western governments play in Africa.

SOUTH AFRICA: Sexual abuse behind bars

JOHANNESBURG - Sexual abuse is widespread in South Africa's prisons, but the provision of health services to this vulnerable population remains problematic.

OVC may be at greater risk of sexual abuse

Girls who have been orphaned may be twice as likely to experience sexual abuse, according to research from child-friendly clinics in Zimbabwe's capital, Harare.

Operation Murambatsvina haunts another proposed clean-up operation

A planned urban clean-up campaign in Zimbabwe's capital, Harare, motivated by health and safety concerns has evoked fears among some residents of a re-run of President Robert Mugabe's iron-fisted Operation Murambatsvina in 2005.

Mugabe the only free Zimbabwean

Zimbabweans have learnt to accept the unacceptable.

An Analysis of aspects of Obama's speech to Parliament

Obama's speech was skilfully written, he is certainly an intelligent and capable speaker. It was however clear to me while I read through the transcript of his speech that he walks a fine line -- being a Westerner who has roots in Africa, he can make references to those roots as he tries to send his message across to us Africans.

Lonrho's bitter battle to retain the heart of its African empire

Dave Lenigas polishes off his breakfast of two small packets of cereal, as the English summer rain tip-taps against the windows of the Mayfair Hotel in London.

No one feels safe in Zimbabwe. No one’

The BBC’s Mike Thomson, in a series of reports from Zimbabwe in early June, spoke to “a Zimbabwean mother and (13-year-old) daughter who are still too afraid to return home after being abducted and repeatedly raped by militiamen from President Robert Mugabe’s Zanu-PF party a year ago.” (Its symbol is a clenched fist.) Their fear has not lessened despite the new alleged “power-sharing” coalition between Mugabe and the Movement for Democratic Change’s Morgan Tsvangirai.

Zimbabwe: humanitarian situation still dire, says priest

A Zimbabwean Catholic priest has said that Zimbabwe is facing the worst humanitarian crisis since independence.