July 2010 Vol 19, Featured Articles, Agriculture Indaba

Rosie DiManno: Zimbabwe: From breadbasket to basket case

Mon, Jul 26, 2010

Land reform under Robert Mugabe has seen a once productive landscape turn barren and reliant on imports

HARARE—From breadbasket of Africa to African basket case — that’s Zimbabwe.

A country rooted in agriculture that now must import maize and wheat, 7 million of its people targeted for assistance this year by the World Food Program.

At least 85 per cent of the population is unemployed,

49 per cent malnourished according to WFP figures, with 83 per cent living on less than $2 a day.

Zimbabwe: Once the regional model of an African country functioning at maximum capacity; for the past decade in utter economic collapse, wracked by multi-trillion per cent inflation until the Zimbabwe dollar was shelved for U.S. currency last year.

The government blames a nation’s misery on international sanctions and chronic droughts.

The world blames Zimbabwe’s woes on President Robert Mugabe, his Zanu-PF thugocracy, endemic corruption and the catastrophe of land redistribution.

Out of some 6,000 large white-owned commercial farms in 2000, less than 300 remain, with half of those facing eviction orders, 80 seized in the year since a unity government was brokered between Zanu-PF and the Movement for Democratic Change. That indicates very little has actually changed, even with MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirai installed as prime minister.

“Reform?” says Deon Theron, posing the word as a rhetorical question and simultaneously sneering. “Reforming from productive to unproductive, more like it.”

Theron is president of Zimbabwe’s ever-shrinking Commercial Farmers Union, which essentially represents Zimbabwe’s ever-shrinking constituency of white farmers. Since land resettlement legislation in 2000 — taking back for black rural farmers, allegedly, what the white colonizers had staked unilaterally in centuries past — the country has been in economic free fall, unable to feed itself, arable property lying fallow, mud-hut dwellers working tiny plots and selling their produce by the side of the road where formerly massive crop yields were sold to foreign markets.

“It’s been devastating,” says Theron, 56, himself among the white commercial farmers — raising dairy and beef cattle — divested of property without compensation, living now on his mother’s farm, though the elderly woman has also been ordered off her land, despite a High Court ruling that she is the legal owner.

The narrative of white owners driven off their farms by invaders, often violently by youth militia mobs — police looking the other way because they refuse to intervene in anything “political” — has been well-documented since 2000. Yet it’s the far more numerous black farm workers who’ve suffered most as their jobs disappeared, the land usurpers — primarily government and “parastatal” officials, Zimbabwe’s cronies — hopelessly inexperienced at commercial farming.

It’s dispiriting to drive across this country’s highways, looking upon mile after mile of disused land, the Rhodes grass waist-high where once neat furrows of crops were cultivated.

“Mugabe’s policies have destroyed the symbiotic relationship between commercial farmers and small scale farmers,” explains Theron. “They claim to be empowering black citizens but only a small handful of individuals have benefited, Mugabe and his friends.”

Just look at the figures:

Between 2000 and 2008, production of maize declined 79 per cent, wheat 90 per cent, soya beans 66 per cent, citrus 50 per cent, fresh produce 61 per cent, dairy 59 per cent, beef 67 per cent, coffee 92 per cent, tea 40 per cent. Only tobacco, a major foreign currency generator, has rebounded markedly in the last year from a nearly 80 per cent decline.

Theron’s personal story shares all the hallmarks of Mugabe’s assault on white land owners. Three farms Theron bought after Rhodesia/Zimbabwe’s independence in 1980 — none of it inherited — have been seized, with all of the equipment. “They attacked us. They beat up my employees. They slept in my bed, ate my food, drank my beer. They poisoned my dogs and they almost killed me.”

Because he refused to vacate his mother’s farm, Theron was charged and convicted in an absurd kangaroo court trial where the first magistrate had himself taken over a white-owned farm, the second scolded Theron to “face the music for your illegal occupation of the land” and the third refused to allow the defence to present any evidence or call witnesses.

Theron is appealing the six-month sentence handed down two days before Zimbabwe’s last national elections.

“They were desperate for a conviction to show that they were standing up for the rights of black farmers. But very few ordinary people have been given any land.”

Further, Theron adds, urban Zimbabweans graduating from college have no wish to farm; they don’t want to work with their hands, would prefer to sit in front of computers and do technology.

“Listen, I’m not opposed to land redistribution. We all know the colonial history of this country. But what happening isn’t land reform. It’s thuggery.

“There has to be some respect for the rule of law. There has to be restitution and respect for property rights. There has to be an independent judiciary. We don’t have any of that right now.”

There have been small glimpses of progress. The Southern African Development Community, representing regional countries, has ruled in favour of ousted farmers in land ownership disputes and is threatening action against Zimbabwe for refusing to recognize its decisions. Zimbabwe’s High Court has likewise rendered verdicts acknowledging rightful ownership of property. South Africa’s ambassador intervened successfully on behalf of its nationals who were tossed off farm they owned here. The German embassy this month forced Zimbabwe to back off its eviction of a huge farming enterprise owned by a German citizen, threatening to withhold $50 million in humanitarian assistance.

Theron estimates it would cost upwards of $12 billion to compensate white farmers evicted from their property. “The government doesn’t have that kind of money.”

Zimbabwe’s prolonged economic derangement and the resultant collapse of the country’s social infrastructure has been entirely self-afflicted. The government is in staggering debt yet continues to discourage the foreign investment acutely needed to get off its knees. Recent legislation now requires that large foreign-owned companies sell a majority share interest to indigenous Zimbabweans, described as “formerly disadvantaged”. That kind of unfriendly investment climate has put Zimbabwe — which pulled out of the Commonwealth in 2003 — on the wrong side of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund.

The international community also has watched with dismay as Mugabe has thwarted key provisions of the Global Political Agreement that forced power sharing on Zanu-PF — promises to conduct a thorough land audit, to reorganize security forces, to appoint MDC governors and to end arbitrary detentions of political opponents and activists.

Meanwhile, farm seizures continue unabated.

Zimbabwe cannot possibly begin to heal itself as long as the agriculture sector remains in such colossal disarray.

Yet Theron, among others, is hopeful.

“We can still turn this around. Look at the way we stopped the runaway inflation, when all the shops were empty, no food on the shelves. The people did that, by refusing to use Zimbabwe dollars anymore and that forced the government to change their policy.

“I believe we can get back on our feet again pretty quickly, with some decent governance. The agriculture industry will come back. This has always been an agriculture-driven economy — agriculture and foreign investment.”

Salvation might be just a heartbeat away — Mugabe’s heartbeat. He’s 86-years-old. And he’s almost single-handedly holding the widely discredited Zanu-PF together.

“He still has a great deal of respect throughout Africa,” says Theron. “He’s stood up against all the odds. Absolutely, he’s a great patriot. But nobody else in the party has that kind of immunity.

“His death will change everything.”

Then, Theron offers a sheepish smile.

“I am a Zimbabwean. If you’re going to remain in this country, you’ve got to be an optimist.”

Please login to post your comments.

More Featured Articles

CAUGHT CHEATING? HOW TO MOVE FORWARD AFTER BEING UNFAITHFUL

We all learn to look out for signs that our man is cheating, or subtle hints that he might be seeing someone else on the side, but what if you are the one that cheated? Assuming that you still want to work on your current relationship, we have 7 ways to move on successfully after you’ve been unfaithful. This is not a “loop-hole” and is not praised, but the reality is 14 percent of married women have had affairs at least once during their married lives and 17 percent of divorces in the United States are caused by infidelity. If you fall into this category, and don’t want to be part of the divorce statistic, take a look at these helpful steps.

Sure signs she's cheating on you

MARRIAGES often break down on account of husbands not being loyal to their wives.

Who wants to be a monkey?

A student has been left feeling a little red-faced after an embarrassing incident with a monkey made her a global star. Charmian Chen, who just happens to be a model, was visiting the Sacred Monkey Forest Ubud in Bali last month when two of the primates decided she was a little overdressed.The 22-year-old student, from Taiwan, was on holiday on the tropical Indonesian island feeding long-tailed macaques when she was singled out.

Rural Children with HIV a ‘Lost Cause’

GURUVE, Zimbabwe, (IPS) - Eleven-year-old Irene Thembo* lies curled like a foetus on a white wooden bench for outpatients at a clinic in rural Zimbabwe. The orphan, whose parents died of HIV-related illnesses, is terribly sick.

Military junta' rules Zimbabwe - MDC

Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe is little more than the front man for a military junta, senior Movement for Democratic Change leader has said.

Zimbabwean government to allow private investment in energy sector

Zimbabwe will soon open up its doors to investors in the energy sector to invest as independent power producers or public-private partnership arrangement in the development of larger power projects in the country, The Herald said on Tuesday.

ANC study group to learn what makes China tick

Senior ANC members flew to China yesterday for a two-week study tour that will include hearing a lecture on the role of state-owned enterprises.

Lest we forget: Zim violence victims still bitter

Harare - Thandiwe Ncube cannot conceal her pain and bitterness when she speaks about her husband's murder nine years ago by suspected militant backers of Zimbabwe President Robert Mugabe. (Pictured: Mugabe, once boasted having degrees in violence now he seems to have a doctorate as he meticulously exterminates any dissenters)

Mugabe Embraces Polygamy To Win Elections

“Politicians can go to any length in order to win votes and stay in power forever. I was not surprised to see recent pictures of President Robert Mugabe clad in full Apostolic Church regalia holding a hob stick, on a mission to lure the sect members to embrace his leadership. We have always known him to be a devout Roman Catholic”, remarked Leona Kazembe, a Catholic lay leader.

US$1.7 billion diamonds to be auctioned

ZIMBABWE said Wednesday it will “immediately” auction a stockpile of more than 4.5 million carats of diamonds that it has been sitting on during the past nine months due to an international ban on trade in gems from the country’s controversial Marange fields.

Villagers Cry Foul As Chinese Diamond Firm Denies Them Jobs

Mutare, - Anjin China, a Chinese company awarded rights to mine diamonds in Chiadzwa has come under fire from villagers after it emerged it was not offering locals jobs.

Britain to review rejected immigration pleas

London, - The UK Border Agency (UKBA) has announced it will review applications of migrants whose pleas were refused solely because they failed to meet the financial requirements for maintenance.

Biti asked to rein in his brother who is out of control

ZIMBABWE’S Ambassador to Germany, Mr Hebson Makuvise, has challenged MDC-T secretary-general Mr Tendai Biti to counsel his young brother Stanford against bringing MDC-T and the country into disrepute by disseminating falsehoods in the United Kingdom and on the Internet. ( Tendai Biti: Why should he be thy brother's keeper?)

Zimbabwe struggles to get the word out on climate change

HARARE, Zimbabwe (AlertNet) - Seventy-six-year-old Tenge Musasa is flummoxed by the changing climate around her.

Zim Diaspora map education assistance to Zimbabwe

A group of committed Zimbabweans based in the United Kingdom gathered in London to map ways of assisting rehabilitate the education system in Zimbabwe according to a press release via Matebeland.com. (File picure: Lifeless Zimbabwean schools are a result of 30 years of government neglect and are badly in need of funding to get them back on track)

African singer is ‘Rebel’ with a cause

Yes, the United States economy is floundering. Then again, it’s going great compared to what’s happening in Zimbabwe.

Former SAA boss made to pay for abuse of office

Axed South African Airways CEO Khaya Ngqula will not only have to pay more than R30-million to the airline, but could also face criminal charges according to reports from the Times of South Africa.

SA teen's horror on the high seas

Riddle of a South African cadet sailor's drifting body deepens with shocking claims of sexual abuse on board

Mugabe should not have been part of new government- political scientists

VUMBA – Local political scientists meeting here last week said President Robert Mugabe should not have been part of the unity government because he lost the 2008 elections. (Picture: Computer graphics , what Mugabe might look like at the end of another term in office in 2017)

Black British couple give birth to white blue-eyed blonde baby girl

This is the black couple who have amazed medical experts after their baby daughter was born with white skin, blue eyes and blonde hair.

HOT SEAT: Diamond researcher & human rights activist Farai Maguwu

The Hot Seat programme this week is presented by Alex Bell, who speaks to diamond researcher and human rights activist Farai Maguwu. He was finally released on bail this week after his arrest six weeks ago, and he tells Alex about his time in custody and how he was treated. He also gives his reaction to the deal reached this week between the government and the Kimberly Process, which will allow Chiadzwa diamond sales to go ahead.

Inclusive government to continue - Masunungure

HARARE - A leading political scientist has forecast that Zimbabwe will remain stuck with a shared government even if it holds new polls next year as widely predicted as the current situation has not brought reforms necessary for change.

Veggies Dried and Tasted

BULAWAYO - (IPS) - A resurgence of interest in dried traditional vegetables has opened up a market opportunity for women entrepreneurs in Zimbabwe's second city, Bulawayo.

Galleries & report: Zimbabwe Constitutional Consultation Workshop Forest gate (UK)

The Zimbabwean Constitution Coalition (UK), a grouping of Zimbabwean civic organisations formed for the purpose of facilitating Diaspora participation in the writing of a new constitution for Zimbabwe, held a Constitutional workshop on Saturday 17 July, Forest Gate, London.