Skip Navigation

August 2011 - Vol 36, Featured Articles

Wikileaks Tsunami - Will Jonathan Moyo be prosecuted?

By Clifford Chitupa Mashiri   Wed, Sep 07, 2011

Pictured : Jonathan Moyo - No longer a laughing matter.

Wikileaks Tsunami - Will Jonathan Moyo be prosecuted?

OPINION - Jonathan Moyo’s hypocrisy of wining and dining with a supposedly enemy of the Zanu-pf party, the U.S. Ambassador to Zimbabwe has finally been exposed by a leaked cable now available online, courtesy of Wikileaks website.

At his meeting with Ambassador Christopher Dell on 30 March 2007, cable reference id: #07Harare 270, Jonathan Moyo said it was unlikely Mugabe’s decision to run for president in 2008 would have been successfully challenged from within the ruling party.

Moyo noted that Mugabe genuinely fears “hanging” if he leaves office and suggested international guarantees for his safety could help persuade Mugabe to go.

The Ambassador responded that this was a decision for the Zimbabwean people.

Moyo told the Ambassador that Mugabe was stung by criticism at the Zanu-pf December conference of his decision to extend his term until 2010.

Moyo was aware of the results (of an exercise to gauge Mugabe’s support as a candidate for 2008 elections) from seven provinces: the clear sentiment was that he should not run again.

Because of the lack of support from the provinces, Mugabe largely dampened discussion of 2008 in the Politburo meeting.

An interesting theme that can only be explained by Jonathan Moyo himself is what sounds like his obsession with the subject of military coups. For instance, in Mugabe must go now, Moyo said:

“Curiously, this real coup whose tribal story has not yet been told took place on the morning of the same day during which, later in the evening, a coup plot was allegedly hatched at Dinyane High School in Tsholotsho giving rise to the so-called ‘Tsholotsho Declaration”.

In the leaked cable, Moyo told the American Ambassador that he thought it highly unlikely the military would act on its own and stage a coup.

Then in December 2010,  Moyo accused MDC leader Morgan Tsvangirait saying: “As early as 2000 he was actively asking the US to bring troops to Zimbabwe to effect a coup,” (Zimdiaspora, 10/12/10).

Amazingly, in June this year Moyo warned of “the looming danger which will happen as sure as tomorrow is coming. If that happens, all hell will break loose” (Livingstone report now a matter for historians, 19/06/11).

According to the cable, Moyo  told the American Ambassador that surviving members of the General Staff of ZANLA believed Mugabe would be defeated in 2008.

That was not different from his own personal views as expressed through the opinion piece, Mugabe must go now, in which Jonathan Moyo said: “The nation is bleeding and it would be very irresponsible to expect Zimbabweans to wait until 2008 for the presidential elections.”

He then gave what he described as “compelling reasons why Mugabe must follow the constitutional exit door by resigning now.” He said: “Mugabe is now a leader of a shelf political party;” “the rot in Zanu-pf smells in government; government has now resorted to ruling through ‘GBO’ Government By Operations”  and so on.

When he spoke with the American Ambassador, Moyo believed that a Zanu-pf party led by Mugabe was likely to lose any election. He allegedly said that Mugabe had told Mnangangwa that he feared being hung.

Interestingly, many Zanu-pf officials in the leaked cables seemed too keen to impress on American diplomats that Mugabe feared execution for his alleged rights abuses.

On the issue of sanctions the cable recorded that Moyo accepted the placing of policy makers and their families on sanctions lists, but urged “us” (the American government) not to list parliamentarians who are not members of either Zanu-pf Politburo or Central Committee.

Whether his alleged plea for the exemption of MPs had anything to do with his status then, only Moyo can explain that himself.

Ironically, later through his opinion pieces Jonathan Moyo campaigned vigorously for the resignation and arrest of MDC President Morgan Tsvangirai whom he accused of treasonous acts by calling for the retention of sanctions against Zanu-pf inner circle.

“This is treasonous and Tsvangirai should be held accountable for his actions” Jonathan Moyo said.

One is left wondering if it is the same Jonathan  Moyo who was quoted in Cable 07Harare 270, as saying that he had understood a policy of expanding sanctions to include Politburo and Central Committee members (and their families)  because they are in decision making positions.

With the revelations coming from Wikileaks, it remains to be seen how Jonathan Moyo will try to stop the whole world from commenting about his hypocrisy in view of his recent attempts to gag the Zimbabwean independent press from publishing articles which he published criticising Mugabe.

At the instigation of Jonathan Moyo, the Attorney General Johannes Tomana appointed a committee of legal experts to explore if there were any grounds for pressing treason charges against Morgan Tsvangirai and the answer was negative.

Accordingly, it line with the rule of law and transparency, it is only right and proper for a similar committee to be 

By Clifford Chitupa Mashiri

Please login to post your comments.

More Featured Articles

CAUGHT CHEATING? HOW TO MOVE FORWARD AFTER BEING UNFAITHFUL

We all learn to look out for signs that our man is cheating, or subtle hints that he might be seeing someone else on the side, but what if you are the one that cheated? Assuming that you still want to work on your current relationship, we have 7 ways to move on successfully after you’ve been unfaithful. This is not a “loop-hole” and is not praised, but the reality is 14 percent of married women have had affairs at least once during their married lives and 17 percent of divorces in the United States are caused by infidelity. If you fall into this category, and don’t want to be part of the divorce statistic, take a look at these helpful steps.

Sure signs she's cheating on you

MARRIAGES often break down on account of husbands not being loyal to their wives.

Who wants to be a monkey?

A student has been left feeling a little red-faced after an embarrassing incident with a monkey made her a global star. Charmian Chen, who just happens to be a model, was visiting the Sacred Monkey Forest Ubud in Bali last month when two of the primates decided she was a little overdressed.The 22-year-old student, from Taiwan, was on holiday on the tropical Indonesian island feeding long-tailed macaques when she was singled out.

I contemplated taking arms to oust Mugabe

HARARE — MDC-T leader Mr Morgan Tsvangirai says he thought of taking up arms to force himself into power after failing to out rightly win the 2008 presidential election.

Gadhafi death amounts to victory for Obama’s approach

WASHINGTON — President Barack Obama’s doctrine of dealing with American enemies just got another test — and, for him, another vindication.

ZIMBABWE: Some are more indigenous than others

HARARE, - Stallholders at the Mupedzanhamo market on the outskirts of Zimbabwe’s capital, Harare, thought they were immune to the 2008 Indigenisation and Economic Empowerment Act, which requires large businesses such as banks and mining companies to relinquish at least 51 percent of their shares or interests to indigenous Zimbabweans.

Ailing Mugabe's health forcing change

Johannesburg - President Robert Mugabe's failing health has possibly forced his Zanu-PF party to press for early elections in Zimbabwe and accelerate a plan compelling foreign firms to surrender majority shareholdings, but it has not so far loosened his grip on power

Anglicans Must Reunite

The head of 75 million or so Anglicans worldwide, Archbishop of Canterbury Dr Rowan Williams drove into Harare on Sunday and many are asking if he will be shocked by the state of his church here writes Herbert Mugwagwa.

Whoever takes over from Mugabe could be even worse

OPINION: The reported secret moves within SADC to get Mugabe a so-called soft landing (Sunday Times, 09/10/11) do not inspire confidence at all because they are an admission of failure by the regional body to rein in the recalcitrant octogenarian on overdue refor

Walvis Bay Corridor unlocking opportunities for Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe is in the process of developing a dry port at the Port of Walvis Bay with the aim of facilitating the easy importation and exportation of goods especially to and from America and Europe.

Zimbabwe’s young leaders must challenge the old guard

I was honestly very surprised to hear co-Home Affairs minister Theresa Makone’s admission the other day that Mugabe’s ZANU-PF thugs have more power than the police and that her party, the MDC, is powerless to stop the violence.

Sata victory shows the power of youth in shaping future

Veteran Zambian opposition leader Michael Sata built Friday’s election upset on an army of young support fired up by promises of no corruption and lots of jobs, a winning formula that may carry lessons for politics across sub-Saharan Africa.

Reckless Behaviour Fuels HIV Spread

Baby sitting on her lap, she tapped her leg to the blurring sound of sungura music playing in the smoke-filled tavern writes Catherine Murombedzi for Zimpapers.

Zimbabwe's surviving political spouses: silence of the lambs

It is very disturbing how ZANU-PF cowers victims of its violence and political intransigence. Since independence, I have noticed spouses of fallen heroes getting on with their lives without any idea of how their husbands or wives died writes DON-MARTIN ROPAFADZO.

Zimbabwe gets ready for “indigenisation”

In a country that needs foreign capital not to grow but to survive, Zimbabwe’s indigenisation law defies understanding. Although the recent sale by the state of a 54 per cent stake in the Zimbabwe Iron and Steel Company (Zisco) to a Mauritian-based Indian company, Essar Africa, shows that some foreign investors – especially from Asia – are more equal than others, mining companies, regardless of size, have since been singled out for special treatment writes Tony Hawkins

Chinese medical teams adds value to health service in Zimbabwe

HARARE, (Xinhua) -- The Chinese medical teams in Zimbabwe have helped improve the health delivery service in the southern African country and won recognition from the government and its people. In a recent interview with Xinhua, Obadiah Moyo, the chief executive officer of Chitungwiza Central Hospital, described the Chinese doctors as "highly skilled and extremely professional". "They are very experienced and have imparted a lot of knowledge to our local doctors. Their presence has provided a lot of benefits to our population and added value to our health delivery system," he said.

This 'rogue trader' was simply out of his

Rogue traders are an intriguing breed. It's tempting to think of them as pathological liars with an appetite for destruction. As devious, scheming minds, so desperate for personal gain that they are willing to risk the reputations and livelihoods of all around them writes Simon English in the Evening Standard.

Mine investors pick up mixed signals from Zimbabwe

INVESTORS in Zimbabwe’s mining sector are still unsure if they should trust the government’s recent climb-down on threats to seize foreign-owned groups under an indigenisation policy.

Just fire them – what is Mugabe waiting for?

OPINION: Sure, Mugabe cannot say he is not disappointed by the ongoing disclosures of damaging secret meetings held by his presumed lieutenants as reported in those leaked cables on Wikileaks. If so, what is he waiting for? Dithering and inconsistency appear to be Mugabe’s major weaknesses.

Is Mugabe a long term cancer survivor?

WikiLeaks has revealed the long held rumour that Robert Mugabe may have prostrate cancer. But a medical expert said he strongly believes that early treatment could have prevented the disease from spreading to other vital organs of the body.

Mujuru’s death: “Attempts to cook-up story accusing Israel diamond mafia rebuffed”

HARARE - An explosive Zanu PF indaba is in the offing tomorrow as it emerges that close associates of late army commander Retired General Solomon Mujuru are set to push for an explanation from the party on the circumstances that led to the former army boss’ death reports the Daily News

Killer on the loose: Another widow joins the angry ranks in Zimbabwe

Zimbabwe's vice-president Joyce Mujuru is on her way to becoming another inconvenient army widow. Ever since the death early last week in a house fire of her husband, the powerful ex-army chief and presidential contender retired general Solomon Mujuru, officials from president Robert Mugabe's Zanu-PF party have warned that those asking questions are "stoking the fire of hatred". But now Mrs Mujuru says she too finds his death "weird" and wants a "satisfactory" explanation.

Tension mounts over Mujuru death

Discord in Zanu PF over circumstances surrounding the death of former army commander Solomon Mujuru two weeks ago signals widening cracks, division and mounting tension within the former ruling party, analysts and observers have said.

How a General stole a farm: My family’s story – Guy Watson-Smith (2004)

This narrative was written by Zimbabwean farmer Guy Watson-Smith in 2004, recounting his experiences at the hands of General Solomon Mujuru. We are re-printing it as he wrote it at that time. General Mujuru died in a fire earlier this month on August 17th.

Zimbabwe - Leadership succession Vacuum-packed aspirants

While the controversy over whether Gen Solomon Mujuru’s death in a fire at his home last week was accidental or foul play rages on, Zimbabwe’s political parties are reassessing their strategies now that the Zanu-PF kingmaker has gone.

Mad about Conspiracies - ‘Explaining’ the Death of a Retired General?

That conspiracies occur the world over is undeniable but is important to question the rationale, if any, behind conspiracy theories. What purpose do they serve and should anyone take them seriously or dismiss them only as the stuff of fantasy and make believe?